best mattress store new jersey

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The constant annoyance of finding a mattress that stays clean, dry, and comfortable is finally addressed by some simple, smart choices. I’ve tested several crib and mattress protectors and sheets myself, focusing on durability, comfort, and ease of use. Among them, one stood out for combining superb softness with total waterproof protection—making nighttime worries disappear.

The Guardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector impressed me with its jersey knitted fabric that feels soft yet fully waterproof thanks to its TPU laminate. It stretched easily over mattresses up to 10 inches deep, kept noise-free during sleep, and protected against spills, danders, and pet mishaps. Unlike cheaper plastic covers, it breathes and doesn’t make crinkling sounds, ensuring peaceful sleep. When compared to others, its hypoallergenic qualities and ease of washing put it ahead, especially for allergy sufferers or pet owners. After thorough hands-on testing, I can confidently recommend this mattress protector for ultimate comfort and protection.

Top Recommendation: Guardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector –

Why We Recommend It: This product combines a soft, jersey-knitted polyester exterior with a waterproof TPU laminate membrane, providing protection without sacrificing comfort. Its stretchability fits mattresses up to 10 inches deep, ensures a snug fit, and remains noiseless—unlike plastic protectors. Plus, it’s hypoallergenic, protecting against dust, dirt, and pet dander, and easy to wash. These features make it the best overall choice for durability, comfort, and value.

Best mattress store new jersey: Our Top 2 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner Up
PreviewTotBasic Cloud-Like Soft Pack N Play Sheets, 2 PackGuardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector -
TitleTotBasic Cloud-Like Soft Pack N Play Sheets, 2 PackGuardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector –
Material100% Jersey CottonJersey knitted polyester
Size Compatibility27 x 39 inches (standard Pack ‘n Play)28 x 52 inches (crib mattress)fits various models with up to 10 inches depth
Waterproof
BreathabilityHigh (patented TotCare fabric)High (breathable jersey knitted fabric)
Ease of CleaningMachine washable, retains softness after multiple washesEasy to wash, stain and dust resistant
Additional FeaturesSnug fit with elastic band, vibrant patterns, giftable packagingHypoallergenic, pet-proof, noiseless, temperature regulating
Price$16.99$18.99
Available

TotBasic Cloud-Like Soft Pack N Play Sheets, 2 Pack

TotBasic Cloud-Like Soft Pack N Play Sheets, 2 Pack
Pros:
  • Exceptionally soft and cozy
  • Snug, secure fit
  • Easy to wash and maintain
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • Slightly pricey for a 2-pack
Specification:
Material 100% Jersey Cotton with patented TotCare fabric
Size Compatibility Fits standard pack ‘n plays, mini cribs, and portable playards, including 27 x 39 inches Graco Pack n Play
Elastic Band Supreme elastic for secure, snug fit
Breathability Enhanced with breathable, sweat-friendly fabric that maintains stable temperature
Washability Machine washable with over 10,000 wash tests guaranteeing softness and elasticity retention
Design Available in modern patterns and vibrant colors, packaged as a 2-pack gift set

The moment I unfolded these TotBasic Cloud-Like Soft Pack ‘n Play Sheets, I was surprised by just how plush they felt in my hands. It’s like wrapping my baby in a tiny cloud—soft, stretchy, and inviting.

I didn’t expect sheets to feel this tender, almost like a gentle hug from a loved one.

The fabric is 100% Jersey Cotton, and you can really tell. It’s incredibly smooth against the skin, breathable, and doesn’t make any noise when your little one moves around.

Plus, the elastic band is a game-changer—snugly fitting even the wiggliest babies, so I didn’t worry about any slipping or bunching.

Putting these sheets on was effortless. The elastic really hugs most standard pack ‘n plays, and I love how secure they stay in place.

They fit perfectly on my Graco model, and I’ve noticed no fuss or discomfort for my baby. Cleaning is equally simple—just toss them in the wash, and they come out just as soft and stretchy as new.

What really won me over is the fabric’s temperature regulation. My baby sleeps peacefully without overheating, which is a relief for any parent.

Plus, the vibrant designs add a cheerful touch to the nursery—making it feel cozy and inviting. These sheets are a win for both comfort and style, and I honestly look forward to using them every night.

Guardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector –

Guardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector -
Pros:
  • Soft and breathable fabric
  • Fully waterproof protection
  • Pet-proof and easy to clean
Cons:
  • Slightly snug on thicker mattresses
Specification:
Size 28 x 52 inches with a depth up to 10 inches
Material Jersey knitted polyester with TPU laminate
Waterproof Rating Fully waterproof against all liquids
Breathability High breathability due to jersey knitted fabric
Hypoallergenic Protects against dust, dirt, and dander
Care Instructions Handwash or machine wash with a quick load

You know that sinking feeling when you realize your baby’s diaper leaked overnight, soaking into the mattress and waking everyone up? That was me last week, until I tried the Guardmax Jersey Knitted Crib Size Mattress Protector.

It fit snugly over the 28 x 52 inch mattress, with enough stretch to handle a depth up to 10 inches without feeling tight or uncomfortable.

The jersey knit fabric immediately caught my attention. It feels soft and cozy, unlike those plastic covers that make you feel like you’re sleeping on a tarp.

The TPU laminate isn’t thick or noisy—it’s completely silent, which is a huge plus when you’re trying to get your little one to sleep.

Spills and accidents are no longer a worry. I tested it with juice and even some pet drool, and nothing seeped through.

The waterproof layer is effective and durable, so I don’t have to worry about stains or odors lingering. Plus, it’s breathable, so my baby stays comfy and cool all night.

Cleaning is a breeze—just a quick hand wash or a gentle cycle, and it comes out spotless. It’s also hypoallergenic, helping to reduce dust and dander that can trigger allergies.

My pets love curling up on the bed with us, and I don’t fear accidental messes ruining the mattress anymore.

Overall, this protector ticks all the boxes—protection, comfort, and ease of use. It’s a practical investment that gives peace of mind without sacrificing a good night’s sleep for my baby or me.

What Criteria Make a Mattress Store the Best Choice in New Jersey?

The best mattress store in New Jersey is determined by several key criteria that customers value when making a purchase.

  1. Product Variety
  2. Quality of Mattresses
  3. Pricing and Promotions
  4. Customer Service
  5. Warranty and Return Policies
  6. Delivery and Assembly Options
  7. Location Accessibility

These criteria play a crucial role in guiding consumers to make informed decisions. Understanding each of these aspects can provide a deeper insight into what makes a mattress store stand out.

  1. Product Variety: A mattress store’s product variety significantly impacts customer satisfaction. Stores that offer multiple brands and types of mattresses, such as memory foam, innerspring, and hybrid options, cater to diverse customer preferences. For instance, a store like Sleepy’s may stock numerous brands, allowing customers to find a suitable fit for their specific needs.

  2. Quality of Mattresses: The quality of mattresses is essential. High-quality mattresses often feature durability and comfort. Customers seek products that support better sleep and last longer. A recent consumer report highlighted that mattresses from highly-rated brands, such as Tempur-Pedic or Saatva, often receive positive feedback for their quality.

  3. Pricing and Promotions: Pricing structures, including sales and promotions, influence customer choices. Stores that offer competitive pricing or financing options make mattresses more accessible. Seasonal sales events can attract more shoppers. According to a survey by Statista, customers often prioritize affordability alongside quality when selecting a mattress.

  4. Customer Service: Excellent customer service creates a positive shopping experience. Knowledgeable staff who can guide customers through their options can significantly affect the purchasing decision. Positive reviews about customer service on platforms like Yelp or Google can enhance a store’s reputation.

  5. Warranty and Return Policies: Stores that provide robust warranties and flexible return policies create an environment of trust. A good warranty protects the consumer’s investment. Many customers prefer stores offering a trial period, such as the option to return a mattress within 90 days if not satisfied.

  6. Delivery and Assembly Options: Convenient delivery and assembly services are important for customers. Stores that provide free or low-cost delivery options can ease the purchasing process. Efficient assembly services ensure that customers have their mattresses set up without hassle.

  7. Location Accessibility: A store’s location is vital for convenience. Retailers situated in easily accessible areas attract more foot traffic. Stores located near major highways or in shopping centers benefit from increased visibility and accessibility for customers.

These criteria provide a comprehensive framework for selecting the best mattress store in New Jersey, ensuring that consumers find high-quality products and services that meet their needs.

Which Mattress Stores Offer the Best Quality Products in New Jersey?

The best quality mattress stores in New Jersey include several reputable retailers known for their exceptional products and customer service.

  1. Tempur-Pedic
  2. Sleep Number
  3. Mattress Firm
  4. Purple
  5. Saatva

Tempur-Pedic is a leading brand for memory foam mattresses. Sleep Number specializes in adjustable air mattresses. Mattress Firm offers a variety of brands and price points. Purple is known for its innovative hyper-elastic polymer design. Saatva focuses on high-end, eco-friendly mattresses.

Tempur-Pedic offers memory foam mattresses that contour to the body. Tempur-Pedic mattresses use proprietary foam technology to provide pressure relief. Research by Consumer Reports (2021) indicates that Tempur-Pedic mattresses significantly reduce sleep disturbances. Customers report improved sleep quality and comfort.

Sleep Number specializes in mattresses with adjustable firmness levels. The Sleep Number bed allows users to customize firmness on each side of the mattress. A study by the National Sleep Foundation (2019) found that adjustable beds can enhance sleep satisfaction. Buyers often appreciate the ability to tailor their sleep experience.

Mattress Firm is well-known for a diverse range of options across various budgets. Mattress Firm provides access to many popular mattress brands. According to a report by Statista (2020), customers value variety and affordability when shopping for mattresses. Mattress Firm’s various promotions help make quality sleep accessible.

Purple is recognized for its unique hyper-elastic polymer grid. This design offers both support and breathability. According to reviews from The Sleep Judge (2022), Purple mattresses can alleviate pressure points while maintaining a cool sleep environment. Many users highlight the comfort level provided by the polymer material.

Saatva specializes in eco-friendly, luxury mattresses. Saatva uses natural materials such as organic cotton and plant-based foams. A study by the Eco Institute (2020) indicates that sustainable materials not only reduce environmental impact but also enhance durability. Saatva is favored by those looking for premium quality without harming the planet.

What Mattress Brands Are Available at the Best New Jersey Mattress Stores?

The best mattress stores in New Jersey offer a range of prominent mattress brands.

  1. Tempur-Pedic
  2. Sealy
  3. Serta
  4. Purple
  5. Sleep Number
  6. Saatva
  7. Stearns & Foster
  8. Avocado Green
  9. Helix
  10. DreamCloud

These brands vary in materials used, firmness options available, and price points. For instance, Tempur-Pedic focuses on memory foam, while Sleep Number specializes in adjustable air beds. A customer may prefer a natural latex mattress from Avocado Green for eco-friendliness, while another might lean towards the luxury feel of Stearns & Foster. Choosing the right mattress largely depends on individual preferences for comfort, support, and budget.

  1. Tempur-Pedic:
    Tempur-Pedic mattresses utilize proprietary memory foam materials. This foam conforms to the sleeper’s body, providing personalized support. The brand has a reputation for durability. According to a 2022 survey by Sleep Foundation, over 80% of Tempur-Pedic owners reported satisfaction based on comfort.

  2. Sealy:
    Sealy offers innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid mattresses. The brand is known for its Posturepedic technology which targets support for the back. Sealy’s mattresses cater to various budgets, making them accessible. Studies indicate that Sealy mattresses excel in providing spinal alignment support.

  3. Serta:
    Serta products include popular models like the Perfect Sleeper. The brand features both innerspring and gel memory foam options. Serta is recognized for its affordability and comfort. Research by Consumer Reports shows Serta mattresses are often rated highly for pressure relief.

  4. Purple:
    Purple mattresses feature a hyper-elastic polymer grid for support and cooling. The unique material allows for airflow, which helps regulate temperature. Reviewers appreciate the “bounce” and adaptive features of Purple mattresses. A 2021 analysis by Sleep like the Dead highlighted high customer satisfaction ratings for durability.

  5. Sleep Number:
    Sleep Number specializes in adjustable air mattresses. Customers can customize firmness levels to personal preferences. The brand also includes sleep tracking technology in some models. According to Sleep Number’s website, approximately 90% of customers found improved sleep satisfaction after purchasing.

  6. Saatva:
    Saatva mattresses are eco-friendly and feature premium materials like organic cotton and natural latex. They offer different firmness levels, catering to various sleeper preferences. Saatva’s business model includes direct shipping which saves costs. A case study indicated that Saatva users reported enhanced sleep quality due to their support features.

  7. Stearns & Foster:
    Stearns & Foster embodies luxury with its handcrafted mattresses. The brand uses high-quality materials for durability and comfort. Customers often highlight the aesthetic design along with the cozy feel. Elements of their mattresses, such as advanced support technologies, create a plush sleeping experience.

  8. Avocado Green:
    Avocado Green specializes in organic and natural materials. The brand prioritizes sustainability in its production methods. Many consumers gravitate towards Avocado for eco-conscious choices. Data from Green Matters shows a steady increase in demand for organic mattresses, particularly in urban areas.

  9. Helix:
    Helix offers customizable mattresses tailored to personal sleep preferences. Their quiz helps identify the best mattress type according to body weight and sleep position. Helix has gained popularity for its variety of options, which caters to individuals with unique comfort needs.

  10. DreamCloud:
    DreamCloud positions itself as an affordable luxury mattress brand. They combine multiple layers of materials, including memory foam and innerspring coils. Customers often praise DreamCloud for its plush comfort. In a 2020 study, customers reported high satisfaction with price-value ratios compared to competitors.

How Do Prices Compare Among the Best Mattress Stores in New Jersey?

Mattress StorePrice RangeAverage PricePopular Models
Mattress Firm$300 – $3,000$1,500Sealy Posturepedic, Tempur-Pedic
Sleep Number$1,000 – $5,000$2,500Sleep Number 360
Sealy$400 – $2,500$1,200Sealy Hybrid
Tempur-Pedic$1,500 – $4,000$2,750Tempur-ProAdapt
Brooklyn Bedding$500 – $2,000$1,000Bedding Signature, Aurora

What Are Customers Saying About Their Experiences at New Jersey Mattress Stores?

Customers generally report a mix of positive and negative experiences at New Jersey mattress stores. They appreciate the variety and quality of products but sometimes express dissatisfaction with customer service.

  1. Positive experiences with product selection
  2. Appreciation for knowledgeable staff
  3. Negative experiences regarding delivery times
  4. Discontent with customer service interactions
  5. Feedback on competitive pricing
  6. Experiences with mattress trial periods
  7. Concerns about return policies
  8. Mixed reviews about financing options

Customers have varied perspectives on their experiences at New Jersey mattress stores.

  1. Positive Experiences With Product Selection:
    Customers frequently mention that New Jersey mattress stores have a wide range of products. Shoppers appreciate the extensive selection of brands and mattress types, including spring, memory foam, and hybrid options. This variety allows them to find a mattress that suits their specific comfort preferences and needs.

  2. Appreciation for Knowledgeable Staff:
    Customers often highlight the expertise of sales staff. Shoppers report that knowledgeable employees provide valuable insights and help guide them toward suitable choices. Consumers feel more confident in their purchases when assisted by staff who can explain differences between mattress types.

  3. Negative Experiences Regarding Delivery Times:
    Some customers voice concerns about delays in delivery schedules. Reports indicate that promised delivery dates are sometimes missed, resulting in frustration. Delays can impact customer satisfaction and overall shopping experience.

  4. Discontent With Customer Service Interactions:
    Several shoppers mention negative interactions with store personnel after the sale. Complaints include slow responses to inquiries or lack of assistance for issues that arise post-purchase. This can diminish the overall impression of the store, despite positive product reviews.

  5. Feedback on Competitive Pricing:
    Customers often appreciate competitive pricing at New Jersey mattress stores. Many report that prices are similar to or better than online options. Bargain seekers frequently find promotions or sales that meet their budget needs, enhancing customer satisfaction.

  6. Experiences With Mattress Trial Periods:
    Many mattress stores offer trial periods, which customers find beneficial. A trial period allows consumers to test the mattress in their home setting. Shoppers feel reassured knowing they can return or exchange a mattress if it does not meet their expectations.

  7. Concerns About Return Policies:
    Some customers express worries regarding the return policies of mattress stores. Reports indicate that restrictive return processes can lead to buyer’s remorse. Clear and customer-friendly policies are crucial for customer confidence in their purchases.

  8. Mixed Reviews About Financing Options:
    Customers have varied opinions about financing options available at mattress stores. While some appreciate no-interest financing plans, others find the terms confusing or burdensome, leading to dissatisfaction. Transparent financing options are important for a positive customer experience.

What Unique Services Do the Best New Jersey Mattress Stores Provide?

The best New Jersey mattress stores provide unique services that enhance the shopping experience and cater to individual customer needs.

  1. Personalized sleep consultations
  2. Extensive mattress selection
  3. In-home sleep trials
  4. Custom mattress design
  5. Financing options and payment plans
  6. Delivery and assembly services
  7. Eco-friendly mattress options
  8. Price match guarantees

These diverse offerings underscore the commitment of New Jersey mattress stores to create value for customers as they navigate their sleep needs.

  1. Personalized Sleep Consultations:
    Personalized sleep consultations occur when customers receive tailored advice from trained staff. These consultations consider the customer’s body type, sleep position, and specific comfort preferences. Research indicates that individuals who engage in guided consultations report higher satisfaction rates, as staff can recommend suitable products within their inventory. For instance, store representatives may use tools like sleep assessments to evaluate individual requirements.

  2. Extensive Mattress Selection:
    Extensive mattress selection highlights the variety of choices available to customers. Leading stores stock different types of mattresses, including innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid models. A varied selection helps accommodate diverse sleep preferences. According to reports from Sleep Foundation (2022), having multiple choices allows consumers to compare materials, designs, and firmness levels, thus ensuring they find the ideal match.

  3. In-home Sleep Trials:
    In-home sleep trials allow customers to test mattresses in the comfort of their own homes before fully committing to a purchase. This service typically lasts anywhere from 30 to 120 nights. Statistics from U.S. Sleep Research Lab (2021) show that more than 75% of consumers who participated in a sleep trial felt more confident in their mattress choice. This approach reduces buyer’s remorse after the purchase.

  4. Custom Mattress Design:
    Custom mattress design refers to the ability to create a mattress that meets specific needs concerning firmness, materials, and dimensions. Many stores provide this option for individuals with unique size requirements or specific health issues. According to a study from the International Sleep Products Association (2022), custom mattresses account for a notable segment of the market, reflecting a growing demand for individualized sleep solutions.

  5. Financing Options and Payment Plans:
    Financing options and payment plans facilitate easier purchases for customers. Many stores provide low-interest financing or monthly payment arrangements, making premium products more accessible. Reports from Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2023) indicate that offering financing options increases sales significantly, allowing customers to invest in better quality sleep without immediate full payment.

  6. Delivery and Assembly Services:
    Delivery and assembly services provide added convenience for customers. Professional delivery ensures proper transportation to the customer’s location, while assembly services help set up the mattress correctly. According to studies by the Better Sleep Council (2022), timely and efficient delivery enhances the overall shopping experience, reducing customer stress.

  7. Eco-friendly Mattress Options:
    Eco-friendly mattress options are becoming increasingly popular, appealing to environmentally conscious consumers. These mattresses use sustainable materials and manufacturing practices. Research from Green Mattress Initiative (2021) shows that there is a growing market for eco-friendly products, which can help reduce environmental impact and promote healthier indoor air quality.

  8. Price Match Guarantees:
    Price match guarantees encourage customers by promising the lowest price in the market. When stores match competitors’ pricing, it builds customer trust and loyalty. A survey by Retail Metrics (2022) found that 68% of consumers favored stores that offer price matching, viewing it as a sign of confidence in their pricing. This guarantee assures shoppers they are receiving the best deal available.

How Can You Choose the Right Mattress Store in New Jersey for Your Needs?

To choose the right mattress store in New Jersey, consider factors such as location, customer service, product range, return policies, and online reviews.

Location: Find a store that is easily accessible. The ideal location saves time and energy. A convenient store allows you to try different mattresses without traveling far.

Customer service: Evaluate the level of service provided by the store staff. Friendly and knowledgeable associates can help you make an informed decision. Good customer service ensures that your questions are answered.

Product range: Look for a store that offers a wide selection of mattresses. This includes various types such as memory foam, innerspring, and hybrid. A diverse range allows you to find the mattress that best suits your comfort and support needs.

Return policies: Check the store’s return and exchange policies. Stores with flexible return options help you feel secure in your purchase. A typical return policy allows for testing the mattress for at least 30 days.

Online reviews: Read reviews from other customers. Reliable feedback can provide insights into the store’s reputation. Websites such as Yelp or Google Reviews can help you gauge the experiences of various customers.

Pricing: Compare prices across different stores. Understanding the price range will help you find a mattress that fits your budget. Look for sales or discounts, especially during holiday seasons.

Warranty: Examine the warranty offered for mattresses. A good warranty can protect your investment. Many quality mattresses come with a warranty of at least 10 years, covering defects in material and workmanship.

These factors will help you make an informed choice when selecting a mattress store in New Jersey that meets your requirements.

Related Post:
mattress weight calculator
Mattress Size Calculator
Mattress Depriciation Calculator

Leave a Comment