Remove Carpet Safely: Tips to See What’s Under Without Damage

To remove carpet and see what’s underneath, cut the carpet into manageable 3-4 foot sections using a utility knife. Roll up each section and haul it outside for disposal. Clear your work area of furniture and wear gloves. After removal, inspect the carpet padding and flooring for damage.

Detach the carpet from the tack strips that secure it to the floor. Use pliers to gently pull the carpet away without ripping it. If you encounter any staples, remove them carefully to avoid scratching the flooring underneath. Assess the condition of the floor as you go. Look for signs of damage, such as water stains or creaky boards.

Storing the carpet in a dry area prevents mold growth. Consider using furniture sliders to protect the flooring while moving heavy items back into the space. After removing the carpet, you can evaluate the floor’s condition. This process prepares you for cleaning or refinishing options. With the carpet gone, you can now explore your flooring choices, creating a fresh and appealing living space.

What Are the Reasons for Removing Carpet to See What’s Under?

Removing carpet allows homeowners to check the condition of the floor underneath. This process can reveal issues such as damage, allergens, or aesthetic opportunities.

Reasons for Removing Carpet to See What’s Under:
1. Inspect for Damage
2. Assess Allergens and Mold
3. Evaluate Flooring Options
4. Update Home Aesthetic
5. Improve Indoor Air Quality

Removing carpet provides insights into the condition of underlying surfaces while offering opportunities for improvement.

  1. Inspect for Damage:
    Removing carpet allows for a thorough inspection of the floor beneath for any signs of damage. Damage can include water stains, rot, or structural issues. According to a report by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), 14% of homeowners found significant damage under their carpet. Identifying problems early can save on costly repairs later.

  2. Assess Allergens and Mold:
    Removing carpet enables homeowners to check for trapped allergens or mold. Carpets can accumulate dust mites, pet dander, and other allergens over time. The American College of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology states that carpets can harbor these allergens, exacerbating respiratory issues. Detecting mold under carpet can prevent health complications, especially in households with vulnerable members.

  3. Evaluate Flooring Options:
    Once the carpet is removed, homeowners can consider new flooring options. Popular choices may include hardwood, tile, or laminate. These alternatives often require fewer allergens to maintain and may be easier to clean. A survey by the Floor Covering Industry shows that 40% of homeowners replace carpeting with hard surfaces for durability and cleaning ease.

  4. Update Home Aesthetic:
    Removing carpet can lead to a refreshed aesthetic in a living space. Homeowners may discover beautiful hardwood floors or decide to install contemporary flooring materials. According to a study by Remodeling Magazine, kitchen and flooring upgrades can yield a return on investment of 70% to 80% in home resale value.

  5. Improve Indoor Air Quality:
    Remedying carpet installation can improve indoor air quality. Carpets can trap pollutants and moisture, leading to poor air conditions. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) notes that removing carpets can enhance indoor air quality by reducing the accumulation of harmful particles. This change can promote healthier living conditions and comfort in the home.

What Tools Do You Need to Remove Carpet Safely?

To remove carpet safely, you need a few essential tools for the task. These tools ensure you can perform the job without damaging the underlying floor and making the process more efficient.

  1. Utility knife
  2. Pliers
  3. Floor scraper
  4. Tape measure
  5. Dust mask
  6. Gloves
  7. Kneepads
  8. Trash bags
  9. Pry bar

Having the right tools can significantly impact the efficiency and safety of carpet removal. Now, let’s look at each tool in detail.

  1. Utility Knife: The utility knife is used to cut the carpet into manageable strips. This tool has a retractable blade that allows for easy and safe cutting. It is crucial to replace dull blades to ensure clean cuts without fraying the edges.

  2. Pliers: Pliers can help remove carpet tacks or staples from the floor. They provide the necessary grip and leverage. This tool minimizes the risk of injury when dealing with sharp fasteners.

  3. Floor Scraper: A floor scraper is used to remove any adhesive left on the floor after the carpet is pulled up. It has a long handle with a flat blade, making it easier to scrape surfaces without straining your back.

  4. Tape Measure: A tape measure is important for accurately measuring room dimensions. Planning out the cutting process requires knowing how much carpet to cut away, ensuring you don’t remove excess.

  5. Dust Mask: A dust mask protects you from inhaling dust and debris released during the carpet removal process. This is particularly important in older homes where carpets may harbor allergens.

  6. Gloves: Wearing gloves protects your hands from sharp objects and chemicals that may be present in the carpet glue or flooring underneath.

  7. Kneepads: Kneepads provide comfort and protection for your knees while working on the floor. They are especially useful for long periods of kneeling when removing carpet.

  8. Trash Bags: Trash bags are necessary for disposing of old carpet and any debris safely. Keeping your workspace tidy minimizes hazards.

  9. Pry Bar: A pry bar assists in lifting edges of the carpet or pulling up carpet tack strips. It provides better leverage for pulling and avoids damage to the floor underneath.

By using these tools thoughtfully, you can make carpet removal a safer and more effective task.

Which Essential Tools Facilitate Safe Carpet Removal?

To facilitate safe carpet removal, essential tools include protective gear, cutting tools, and extraction equipment.

  1. Protective gear (gloves, masks, knee pads)
  2. Cutting tools (utility knife, carpet cutter, or scissors)
  3. Extraction equipment (carpet scraper, floor scraper, or flooring puller)
  4. Adhesive remover (solvents or commercial removers)
  5. Waste disposal tools (trash bags, bins)

These tools are integral to ensuring a safe and efficient carpet removal process. Each type plays a specific role in protecting individuals and preserving the underlying flooring during the removal.

  1. Protective Gear: Protective gear includes items like gloves, masks, and knee pads. Gloves protect hands from sharp objects and hazardous materials. Masks prevent inhalation of dust and allergens that may become airborne during carpet removal. Knee pads provide comfort and protection while kneeling. According to the American Lung Association, using masks can significantly reduce respiratory issues from inhaling particulate matter.

  2. Cutting Tools: Cutting tools, such as utility knives and carpet cutters, are used to carefully loosen and cut the carpet. A utility knife is effective for cutting through carpet seams, while a carpet cutter allows for more precise cuts. As highlighted by Home Repair Tutor, using sharp cutting tools minimizes the effort required and improves safety. When using these tools, individuals should always cut away from their bodies to prevent injuries.

  3. Extraction Equipment: Extraction equipment includes carpet scrapers and floor scrapers. These tools help lift the carpet from the subfloor without damaging it. For instance, a carpet scraper can effectively detach carpet staples or tacks. The National Association of Home Builders recommends using such tools to avoid unnecessary damage to flooring beneath the carpet during removal.

  4. Adhesive Remover: Adhesive remover is necessary for carpets that are glued down. Solvents or commercial adhesive removers break down the glue, making it easier to lift the carpet. According to research by the Carpet and Rug Institute, using the right adhesive remover can decrease residue left on the floor, ensuring a cleaner and safer environment for subsequent flooring installations.

  5. Waste Disposal Tools: Waste disposal tools, including trash bags and bins, facilitate the organized disposal of removed carpet materials. Efficiently managing waste helps maintain a clean work area and improves safety by reducing tripping hazards, as discussed in a study by the National Safety Council.

Utilizing these essential tools will ensure a smooth, safe, and effective carpet removal process.

How Important is Safety Gear During Carpet Removal?

Safety gear is extremely important during carpet removal. It protects individuals from potential hazards associated with the process. The main components involved in safety gear for carpet removal include gloves, masks, knee pads, and safety glasses.

Using gloves protects your hands from sharp tools and rough materials. This step is essential, as injuries can occur from handling carpet staples or sharp edges. Masks filter dust and allergens released during the removal process. Breathing in these particles can harm your respiratory system, making this protection necessary.

Knee pads provide comfort and protection for your knees when working on the floor. Removing carpet often requires crouching or kneeling, which can lead to discomfort or injury without proper support. Safety glasses shield your eyes from debris and dust, preventing possible eye injuries as you cut or pull up the carpet.

In summary, using safety gear during carpet removal reduces the risk of injuries and promotes a safer working environment. Each type of gear serves a specific purpose that addresses potential hazards, making it crucial for a successful removal process.

What Steps Should You Follow to Remove Carpet Without Damaging the Underlying Surface?

To remove carpet without damaging the underlying surface, follow these steps carefully.

  1. Gather necessary tools.
  2. Clear the room of furniture and items.
  3. Cut the carpet into manageable sections.
  4. Detach the carpet from the tack strips.
  5. Remove the padding.
  6. Clean the subfloor.

These steps are essential for ensuring a successful carpet removal. While they provide a basic framework, it’s important to consider specific circumstances that may alter the approach. For instance, the type of subfloor—whether it’s hardwood, concrete, or tile—might require different care during removal. Additionally, opinions may vary regarding the necessity of professional help. Some might advocate for DIY methods, while others emphasize hiring professionals to prevent accidental damage.

1. Gather Necessary Tools:
Gather necessary tools for the carpet removal process. Basic tools include a utility knife, pliers, and a pry bar. Using the right tools minimizes the risk of damage. Having a heavy-duty garbage bag for debris disposal is also advised.

2. Clear the Room of Furniture and Items:
Clearing the room of furniture and items facilitates easier access to the carpet. Removing all obstacles helps ensure that the carpet removal goes smoothly. Otherwise, items could get in the way or be damaged during the process.

3. Cut the Carpet into Manageable Sections:
Cutting the carpet into manageable sections eases removal and handling. Use a utility knife to make straight cuts while ensuring the subfloor remains undamaged beneath. Smaller sections are also easier to carry and dispose of.

4. Detach the Carpet from the Tack Strips:
Detaching the carpet from the tack strips is crucial for avoiding damage. Tack strips are small wooden boards with sharp nails that hold the carpet in place. Use pliers to gently pull the carpet away from these strips to minimize tearing.

5. Remove the Padding:
Remove the padding underneath the carpet carefully. The padding often contains adhesive that can stick to the subfloor. Use a utility knife to cut it into sections and peel it away, ensuring minimal disturbance to the underlying surface.

6. Clean the Subfloor:
After the carpet and padding are removed, clean the subfloor thoroughly. This ensures any residual adhesive or dirt does not affect future flooring installations. A vacuum cleaner or broom is effective for this purpose.

By following these steps, you can successfully remove carpet and protect the underlying surface from damage.

How Can You Prepare a Room Effectively Before Carpet Removal?

To prepare a room effectively before carpet removal, you should clear the area, gather necessary tools, protect the environment, and plan for disposal of the old carpet.

Clear the area: Move all furniture and items from the room. This step ensures that you have enough space to work safely and efficiently. Remove small items, such as lamps and decor, to prevent damage. Use furniture sliders to safely shift heavier pieces without causing injury or floor damage.

Gather necessary tools: Collect all required tools before starting the project. You will need a utility knife, pliers, pry bar, and safety gear such as gloves and goggles. Having everything on hand prevents interruptions during carpet removal.

Protect the environment: Cover any vents, doors, and nearby surfaces to minimize dust and damage. Use drop cloths or plastic sheets to shield floors and walls. This practice helps maintain cleanliness and protects your home during the removal process.

Plan for disposal: Research local regulations for carpet disposal. Many areas require specific methods for disposing of or recycling carpets. Consider donating usable carpet to local charities. This approach can provide a second life to materials that are still functional.

By following these steps, you can ensure a smooth and effective carpet removal process.

What Techniques Work Best for Cutting and Lifting Carpet?

The best techniques for cutting and lifting carpet include using proper tools, employing systematic methods, and considering safety measures.

  1. Proper Tools
  2. Systematic Lifting Techniques
  3. Safety Measures
  4. Potential Conflicting Opinions on Techniques

Employing proper techniques for cutting and lifting carpet can enhance the efficiency and safety of the task. Each technique offers different advantages and can cater to specific needs.

  1. Proper Tools:
    Using proper tools is essential for cutting and lifting carpet effectively. Recommended tools include a utility knife with a sharp blade, a carpet stretcher, and a knee kicker. These tools provide precision and ease of use. According to flooring experts, a utility knife ensures clean cuts without fraying. A carpet stretcher and knee kicker help to lift and secure the carpet properly, preventing any ripples or bubbles.

  2. Systematic Lifting Techniques:
    Systematic lifting techniques involve a step-by-step approach to avoid damage. First, remove any furniture from the carpeted area. Next, cut along the seams or edges using the utility knife. Then, slowly pull the carpet away from the tack strips while ensuring no damage occurs to the underlying foam or flooring. This approach minimizes the risk of tears and enhances the overall result. Case studies show that systematic lifting can increase productivity and reduce the risk of carpet damage.

  3. Safety Measures:
    Safety measures are crucial when cutting and lifting carpet. Proper protective gear, such as gloves and knee pads, should be worn to prevent injuries. Work in a well-lit area to ensure visibility. It is essential to keep the workspace tidy to avoid tripping hazards. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) highlights the importance of these measures in preventing workplace accidents, even in home projects.

  4. Potential Conflicting Opinions on Techniques:
    Some individuals may argue against using specific tools, preferring alternative methods like rolling the carpet instead of lifting or using power tools for cutting. These preferences can lead to differing results based on personal experience. Research indicates that while some methods may save time, they can involve a higher risk of damage to the carpet. The effectiveness of various techniques often depends on the situation and individual skill levels, making it important to consider multiple perspectives.

By adopting proper tools, systematic lifting techniques, and safety measures, one can efficiently cut and lift carpet without damaging the underlying surfaces.

What Should You Look for Under the Carpet Once It’s Removed?

To assess the condition of your flooring and subfloor after carpet removal, you should look for several key elements.

  1. Subfloor condition
  2. Moisture or water damage
  3. Carpet padding residue
  4. Adhesive remnants
  5. Floor levelness
  6. Pest infestation signs
  7. Electrical or plumbing issues

These points are crucial to consider as they can affect your renovation or flooring project.

  1. Subfloor Condition:
    You should examine the subfloor condition after carpet removal. The subfloor is the structural layer beneath the carpet and can be made of wood or concrete. It should be flat and free of damage. A damaged subfloor can lead to uneven surfaces and affect the installation of any new flooring.

  2. Moisture or Water Damage:
    Inspect for moisture or water damage. This is critical as it can cause mold growth and structural issues. Look for discoloration, warping, or a musty smell, which can indicate significant moisture issues. It’s essential to address any leaks or water issues before proceeding further.

  3. Carpet Padding Residue:
    Check for carpet padding residue remaining on the subfloor. This material can leave behind sticky residue that can affect new flooring installation. It is important to remove all remnants for a proper surface.

  4. Adhesive Remnants:
    Look for adhesive remnants if glue-down carpets were used. Adhesives might be difficult to remove fully and can also interfere with new flooring. It’s advisable to use appropriate solvents or scrapers to clear these residues.

  5. Floor Levelness:
    Assess the floor levelness to ensure it is even across the entire area. Uneven floors can lead to problems with the installation of new flooring. A level floor is important for aesthetics and functionality.

  6. Pest Infestation Signs:
    Inspect for pest infestation signs, such as droppings or chew marks. Animals like termites can cause significant damage over time. If signs are present, you may need to consult with pest control professionals.

  7. Electrical or Plumbing Issues:
    Check for any visible electrical or plumbing issues. Exposed wires or leaking pipes can pose safety hazards. Addressing these problems before reflooring ensures safety and compliance with building codes.

How Can You Identify Damage Underneath the Carpet?

You can identify damage underneath the carpet by checking for visible signs, using specific tools, and taking methodical steps to assess the situation.

Visible signs: Look for any noticeable changes in the carpet, such as discoloration or damp patches. These signs often indicate water damage or mold growth. Discoloration could suggest wear and tear, while dampness might suggest leaks or spills.

Lifting furniture: Move heavy furniture to inspect the carpet beneath. This will allow you to reveal hidden areas where damage may be present. Avoid excessive force to prevent further damage to the carpet and floor.

Using a moisture meter: A moisture meter is a tool that can measure the humidity levels in the carpet and the underlying floor. High moisture readings can imply water damage or the presence of mold.

Conducting a smell test: Notice any unusual odors. A musty smell can indicate dampness or mold, which often exists beneath the carpet.

Inspecting seams and seams: Check the edges and seams of the carpet for fraying or curling. These can signal wear, potential water damage, or installation issues.

Checking for softness or bulges: Walk on the carpet and pay attention to any soft spots or bulges. These might indicate problems like water damage or even pest issues beneath the carpet.

Looking for pest signs: Listen for sounds or look for droppings. Certain pests, including termites or rodents, can cause damage underneath carpets.

Using these methods can help you thoroughly assess the condition beneath the carpet without causing additional harm to the flooring.

What Common Underfloor Issues Should You Expect?

Common underfloor issues to expect include insufficient insulation, pest infestations, moisture problems, uneven flooring, and structural damage.

  1. Insufficient Insulation
  2. Pest Infestations
  3. Moisture Problems
  4. Uneven Flooring
  5. Structural Damage

These issues highlight the variety of factors that can affect underfloor conditions, from environmental to biological influences. Understanding these problems is crucial for effective maintenance and prevention.

  1. Insufficient Insulation: Insufficient insulation occurs when there is inadequate material installed to minimize heat loss or gain under the flooring. This can lead to higher energy bills and uncomfortable living conditions. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, properly insulated floors can reduce energy costs by 15%-30%. Inadequately insulated areas often feel cold and drafty, indicating potential thermal inefficiencies.

  2. Pest Infestations: Pest infestations happen when rodents or insects enter the underfloor space. Common pests like termites, ants, and mice can cause significant structural damage and health hazards. The National Pest Management Association states that about 20% of homes in the United States suffer from pest issues. For instance, termites can weaken wooden structures over time, leading to costly repairs.

  3. Moisture Problems: Moisture problems arise from inadequate drainage or leaks that lead to dampness under the floor. Excess moisture can promote mold growth and create a breeding ground for bacteria. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) warns that mold exposure can cause respiratory issues and allergic reactions. Addressing leaks quickly and installing vapor barriers can help mitigate these risks.

  4. Uneven Flooring: Uneven flooring refers to discrepancies in the floor surface that can be caused by settling, rot, or pest damage. Homeowners may notice creaks or slants in the flooring. The American Society of Home Inspectors suggests that uneven floors can indicate underlying structural issues, which require immediate attention to avoid further damage.

  5. Structural Damage: Structural damage encompasses significant issues affecting the overall integrity of the home, such as rotting beams or joists. This may result from long-term moisture exposure or pest activity. According to the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety, structural failure can lead to severe safety hazards and necessitates expensive repairs. Regular inspections can help identify potential problems early on.

What Actions Should You Take After Removing the Carpet?

After removing the carpet, several important actions should be taken to ensure the area is clean, safe, and ready for the next step.

  1. Inspect the Subfloor
  2. Clean the Area
  3. Address Any Damages
  4. Assess Moisture Levels
  5. Consider Flooring Options

Taking these actions prepares your space for any future improvements. Now, let’s elaborate on each of these steps.

  1. Inspect the Subfloor: Inspecting the subfloor involves checking for any signs of damage or deterioration underneath the carpet. A subfloor can be made of wood, concrete, or other materials. If there are issues such as warping or softness in wooden subfloors, these may indicate moisture problems or a compromised structural integrity. Regular maintenance is crucial to prevent further damage.

  2. Clean the Area: Cleaning the area is essential after removing the carpet. Dust, debris, and potential allergens often accumulate below the carpet. It’s important to vacuum the exposed area thoroughly and consider using a damp mop if the surface is hard, or a proper cleaner for wood or other materials. A clean area not only prepares it for new flooring but also contributes to a healthier indoor environment.

  3. Address Any Damages: Addressing any damages found during the inspection is vital. This may involve repairing cracks in a concrete subfloor, replacing damaged wooden planks, or treating any signs of mold or mildew. Prompt repairs can prevent further degradation of the subfloor and provide a stable foundation for new flooring options.

  4. Assess Moisture Levels: Assessing moisture levels is another critical step. High humidity or moisture can lead to mold growth and future issues. Use a moisture meter to check the subfloor’s moisture content. If levels are high, identifying and resolving the source of moisture is necessary to avoid future complications.

  5. Consider Flooring Options: Considering flooring options means evaluating what type of flooring would be best suited for the space. Different materials offer varying advantages. For example, hardwood offers warmth and aesthetic appeal, while tile provides durability and water resistance. Choosing the right option can enhance the room’s functionality and style.

By following these steps, you can ensure a smooth transition from carpet to the next flooring choice while maintaining a safe and clean environment.

How Can You Clean and Restore the Underlying Surface?

To clean and restore the underlying surface beneath a carpet, follow these steps: remove the carpet safely, clean the surface thoroughly, and allow it to dry completely before any restoration.

  1. Remove the carpet: Begin by lifting the carpet carefully to avoid damage. Use pliers or a floor scraper if necessary. Roll up the carpet and set it aside. This exposes the surface underneath while minimizing potential tears or snags.

  2. Clean the surface: After removing the carpet, clean the exposed flooring. Here are some cleaning methods based on the type of underlying surface:
    Wood floors: Use a vacuum to remove dust and debris. Follow with a damp cloth and a wood-cleaning solution. Avoid excessive moisture.
    Concrete: Sweep the surface and mop it with a mixture of water and a cleaning agent suitable for concrete. For stained areas, a stiff brush may help.
    Tile: Vacuum and then mop the tile with a pH-neutral cleaner. For grout, use a specialized grout cleaner and scrub gently using a brush.

  3. Dry the surface: Ensure the cleaned surface is dry before replacing the carpet. Use fans or open windows to improve air circulation. A completely dry surface prevents mold or mildew growth.

  4. Assess for repairs: Inspect the underlying surface for damage, such as cracks or gouges. Repair any issues before reinstalling the carpet. This may involve filling cracks with suitable fillers or sanding down rough spots.

  5. Final restoration: If the surface requires additional restoration, consider using a sealant or polish appropriate for the material. This can enhance the appearance and provide a protective layer.

Following these steps ensures that the underlying surface is clean, restored, and prepared for carpet replacement, maintaining long-term health and aesthetics.

What Are Your Flooring Options After Carpet Removal?

After removing carpet, homeowners can explore various flooring options to suit their style and needs.

  1. Hardwood
  2. Laminate
  3. Vinyl
  4. Tile
  5. Carpet Tiles
  6. Bamboo
  7. Cork

Choosing the right flooring involves considering factors like durability, maintenance, aesthetics, and budget. Each option presents unique advantages and can present different challenges.

  1. Hardwood:
    Hardwood flooring offers a classic, timeless aesthetic. It is composed of solid wood planks and provides warmth and character to a home. According to the National Association of Realtors, hardwood floors can enhance property value. However, it requires regular maintenance like sanding and refinishing every few years. Humidity and moisture can also affect hardwood, leading to warping.

  2. Laminate:
    Laminate flooring mimics the appearance of wood or stone at a lower cost. It consists of a high-density fiberboard core with a photographic layer on top. This option is scratch-resistant and easy to install, making it appealing to many homeowners. However, according to Consumer Reports, laminate cannot be refinished like hardwood and typically lasts 15-25 years.

  3. Vinyl:
    Vinyl flooring is made from synthetic materials and is available in tiles or sheets. It is water-resistant and durable, making it suitable for areas like kitchens and bathrooms. The Resilient Floor Covering Institute states that modern vinyl can replicate natural materials but requires proper installation to avoid seams lifting or curling.

  4. Tile:
    Tile flooring is made from ceramic or porcelain and is known for its durability and water resistance. It is ideal for high-moisture areas and is easy to clean. The American Institute of Architects notes that tile offers extensive design options. However, tiles can be cold underfoot and may require professional installation due to their weight.

  5. Carpet Tiles:
    Carpet tiles are squares of carpet that can be arranged in various patterns. They provide flexibility in design and are easy to install and replace if damaged. According to sources from HGTV, they are also good for sound insulation. However, their lifespan may be shorter than traditional broadloom carpets.

  6. Bamboo:
    Bamboo flooring is a sustainable alternative known for its strength and aesthetic appeal. It has a unique look that can enhance modern décor. However, as documented by the Forest Stewardship Council, some bamboo products can be susceptible to scratches and dents if not properly cared for.

  7. Cork:
    Cork flooring is made from the bark of cork oak trees. It is eco-friendly, provides excellent insulation, and is comfortable underfoot. According to the Cork Institute of America, cork naturally resists mold and mildew. However, it can be damaged by heavy furniture and requires sealing to maintain its appearance.

In summary, homeowners have diverse flooring choices after carpet removal. Each option varies in aesthetics, durability, maintenance, and overall cost. By considering these attributes, one can make an informed decision that best aligns with their preferences and lifestyle.

Related Post:
mattress weight calculator
Mattress Size Calculator
Mattress Depriciation Calculator

Leave a Comment